Skip to content
Main Menu
  • About the Firm
  • Our People
  • Our Expertise
      Alter Ego and Entity Relationships
      Business Valuation
      Construction Disputes
      Economic Damages
      Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
      Forensic Accounting – Compliance with GAAP and GAAS
      Forensic Accounting – Investigations of Improprieties
      Intellectual Property Damages
      Intellectual Property Valuation and Licensing
      Labor Disputes
      Large-Scale Data
      Management Advisory Services
      Royalty and License Compliance Examinations
      White Collar Crime Investigations
  • Offices
      Chico
      Concord
      Fresno
      Los Angeles
      San Francisco
      San Mateo
      Santa Rosa
  • Insights & News
  • Opportunities
  • About the Firm
  • Our People
  • Our Expertise
    • Alter Ego and Entity Relationships
    • Construction Disputes
    • Economic Damages
    • Business Valuation
    • Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
    • Forensic Accounting – Compliance with GAAP and GAAS
    • Forensic Accounting – Investigations of Improprieties
    • Intellectual Property Damages
    • Intellectual Property Valuation and Licensing
    • Labor Disputes
    • Management Advisory Services
    • Royalty and License Compliance Examinations
    • White Collar Crime Investigations
    • Large-Scale Data
  • Offices
    • San Francisco – Bay Area
      • Concord
      • San Francisco
      • San Mateo
      • Santa Rosa
    • Los Angeles
    • Chico
    • Fresno
  • Insights & News
  • Opportunities
Home  /  Insight & News  /  Jury Awards $293 Verdict to Monster Energy Based on Testimony by Hemming Morse Expert Christian Tregillis Regarding Lost Profits Damages and Wrongfully Made Sales of Energy Drink Bang

Jury Awards $293 Verdict to Monster Energy Based on Testimony by Hemming Morse Expert Christian Tregillis Regarding Lost Profits Damages and Wrongfully Made Sales of Energy Drink Bang

  • September, 2022

A jury in California returned a verdict for $293 million for Monster Energy in its case against competitor VPX Pharmaceuticals, the manufacturer of energy drink Bang, relying on and using dagrs calculations made by Hemming Morse, to which partner Christian Tregillis testified. The award included $272 million of lost profits relating to advertising of Bang as containing “super creatine,” which was found to have been false, as well as claims for interference with Monster Energy’s contracts for specific shelf space at retailer locations, and theft of Monster Energy’s trade secrets when former Monster Energy employees took electronic information with them and used it after joining VPX.

 

Mr. Tregillis used a survey, among other information, to estimate what portion of Bang sales would have been Monster sales in a “but-for world” of no false advertising, presenting three alternative scenarios to the jury, ranging from 19% to 34% sales being wrongful, and a portion of those going to Monster. The jury ultimately selected the highest of the lost profits figures presented by Mr. Tregillis. There remains open the issue if whether Monster Energy will be entitled to a disgorgement of VPX’s profits on the rest of the alleged wrongful sales that did not go to Monster Energy, with the district court judge to decide that issue in the second phase of the trial.

 

The award is believed to be the largest false advertising jury verdict in the history of American jurisprudence.

 

For the trade secret damages, Mr. Tregillis estimated the “over-performance” of Bang sales in Georgia, a state in which certain Monster trade secret information was used by a sales representative who left Monster Energy to join VPX, compared to other states, indexing to December of 2018, the month prior to the departure of that employee.

https://www.reuters.com/legal/litigation/monster-energy-wins-293-mln-false-advertising-verdict-against-rival-bang-2022-09-30/

Monster Wins $293M Verdict Against VPX In False Ad Trial

Monster Lost $272M From VPX’s Alleged False Ads, Jury Told

Back to all articles
Hm-rebrandlogos-Finals-2019
Firm Information
  • About the Firm
  • Our People
  • Our Expertise
  • Insights & News
  • Opportunities
Office Locations
  • San Francisco
  • San Mateo
  • Los Angeles
  • Concord
  • Santa Rosa
  • Fresno
  • Chico
Have Questions?
Inquire about a potential matter
Inquire about joining our team
  • Copyright © 2008-2019 Hemming Morse, LLP. All rights reserved.
  • Branding and Web by Red Mallard